Shahar Solomianik

Since Twitter allows only 140 characters…

Crowd Sourcing Sucked, So I Put Instagram API to Work Instead

with 30 comments

I’m a hacker. And a surfer (Surprisingly, not such a rare combination). About a year ago I decided I’ve had enough with the poor quality of real time surf reports. Advanced surf forecasts are available, some surf cams on various beaches are installed, and yet without having a precise view of the surf at any given moment, I found myself too often wasting precious time (otherwise spent hacking) driving to the beach to find poor surfing conditions, or on the other hand, dismissing the drive just to be sorry later when I got the “dude, it was pumpin so awesome, u should have come!” line from someone who did surf.

So I developed [the 1st version of] SwellPhone, a service for “producing and consuming real-time surf reports” in my declarative way of describing it. I reckoned that if I give the surfing community a tool to share photos and videos of the surf that they take just before or after surfing, I will revolutionize real-time surf reporting. Hell, why not? You have a smartphone right? Why not point it to the surf, take a video or photo and help other surfers tell the surfing conditions?

It was a noble idea. It even got to the front page of HackerNews. But I was so naive… Everybody wanted to “consume” the surf reports alright. Just about everybody. However, No one was willing to “produce” a surf report. Absolutely no one. And without anyone producing, there was nothing to actually consume.

I was trying to crowd source surf reporting. But the crowd simply didn’t want to source. Crowd sourcing sucked.

I let SwellPhone linger and diverted my energy elsewhere

Until some day, when while at Intsagram, I stumbled upon this pic of a cute little girl in the Maldives, and it made me laugh, so I Gimped it to express my thoughts:



Then I took another look at the pic and it hit me: Any surfer within a driving distance from this awesome tube who would get to see this photo in a timely manner after it had been taken, would simply leave everything and rush to surf there. Dude, this is not a pic of a cute girl. This is a surf report!

Wait, it’s taken from Instagram, do they have an API? Yes, they do!

Wait, do they geo tag the pics? Yes, they do!

Wait, do they timestamp the pic? Off course they do!

Wait, is there sufficient inventory of pics around known surf spots at any given time? Well, sometimes there is!

Hooray! SwellPhone can rise again! This time though, without the reliance on the crowd to source pics to SwellPhone. People already take thousands of pics of their kids, tanned legs and bellys, gorgeous looking girlfriends/boyfriends, and let’s not forget the empty beer bottles stuck in the sand. All of them have some view of the surf in the background. For us surfers, this is the foreground…

So there you have it. SwellPhone is on again. The site isn’t awesome looking, I know, I suck at design… But I developed phonegap apps for both iOS and Android as well and the UX is much better there.

All in all, it was a lesson to me, and I learnt something. Crowd sourcing can sometimes suck. But that doesn’t mean the data you need is not already sourced in some other manner.


Written by Isaac Trond

September 27, 2012 at 5:51 am

30 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Your app isn’t just for surfers! I’m caribbean and I use swellphone to watch, every now and then, an up-to-date picture of my favourite beach, where I used to chill and picnic before I leave for this cold land.



    September 27, 2012 at 8:39 am

  2. Dude, fix the typos on the description of your app

    “see the surfing conditios in thousnads”


    September 27, 2012 at 8:47 am

  3. Yay, you fixed it.


    September 27, 2012 at 9:10 am

  4. Hehe love your sollution. And indeed leaves space for a lot of similar services.

    Sorel Mihai

    September 27, 2012 at 11:54 am

  5. Dude, you’re a genius. Full stop.

    Pier Paolo Ramon

    September 27, 2012 at 12:40 pm

  6. @Gubatron: if you’ve never surfed the conditios in Thousnads, you don’t know what you’re missing. Best surf ever!

    Len Jaffe

    September 27, 2012 at 1:31 pm

  7. I know the genie is out of the bottle but real surfers don’t necessarily want or need to broadcast to the world when the surf is going off. It’s hard enough as it is scoring an uncrowded session when there’s good waves and 50,000 surfers within driving distance haven’t seen it coming for a week with all the other forecasting and charting tools out there. I’ll call up my bro’s when a sneaker swell shows up and conditions somehow change for the better from what’s been forecast. I certainly don’t need to send up a flare to the masses. Other than that…nice app!


    September 27, 2012 at 1:57 pm

  8. […] Crowd Sourcing Sucked, So I Put Instagram API to Toil Instead … google_ad_client = "pub-4981223025489343"; google_ad_width = 468; google_ad_height = 60; […]

  9. Crowd Sourcing is good but in this case only among surfers.


    September 28, 2012 at 1:59 am

  10. Dude!!!! You kick ass. Kudos for a very original idea. Being also a hacker surfer, and probably surfing the same breaks as you do (also from Tel Aviv), I find this an awesome initiative. I’ll make sure to tag my Instagram photos from now on whenever there’s some piece of water in the photo 🙂

    Gur Dotan

    September 28, 2012 at 7:52 am

  11. There are a lot of products out there but we can’t all afford celebrity prices. I have been using Revitol Eye Cream seems to work and isn’t a crazy price.

    Leeann Guinane

    May 16, 2013 at 12:39 pm

  12. They didn’t realize how much people love their bed bath and beyond coupon. Whiskas cat food Bed Bath And Beyond Coupon locally, you will be able to do that, said Boal. They always have some sort of Six Flags Coupon that you can receive with additional money saving offers.

    Feel free to visit my web-site :: bed bath and beyond coupons :: ::

  13. With that said, this is my pick for the number one
    movie of 2012:. , whether in terms of content and presentation or stardom.

    The performances from Emma Watson, Ezra Miller, and Logan Lerman were
    stellar, creating an infallible suspension of disbelief.
    These days, we tend to overbook our children with so many activities
    that there is little room in their busy lives to fit in
    a new priority. Agreed, that is not free, but nevertheless if you downloaded only two movies each week that would equate to only 19 cents each movie.


    September 18, 2013 at 9:42 pm

  14. Hello,I read your blogs named “Crowd Sourcing Sucked, So I Put Instagram API to Work Instead | Shahar Solomianik” daily.Your it up! And you can look our website aboot oakley black friday

    oakley black friday

    November 28, 2013 at 3:23 am

  15. I’m extremely impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your weblog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the excellent quality writing, it’s rare to see a nice blog like this one nowadays..
    mulberry fashion

    mulberry fashion

    February 9, 2014 at 5:52 pm

  16. Wow, marvelous blog structure! How long have you ever been blogging for? you made running a blog glance easy. The whole glance of your web site is great, as smartly as the content material!
    mulberry daria medium hobo

    mulberry daria medium hobo

    February 9, 2014 at 5:53 pm

  17. 88888 He was young than she, a lot of younger that at the beginning Janie dared not presume during the pleasure he introduced to her. Appleshaped bridesmaids can increase their curves by donning drop waist and detailed neckline.
    buy louis vuitton eva clutch

  18. The shoes are created from fine quality outsoles that are normally made from polyurethane in addition to rubber. A chart can help your child see what he is doing well,Beats Tour Pas Cher, high level immune functionsTheta 4 – 7 Hz more relaxation,Heartbeats Pas Cher, GQ,Powerbeats Pas Cher,Just keep in about mind that alcoholic can affect several factors that shop into making you a faster and simply fitter runner. you will find some instances that will be fixed with some kind of medical procedure

    DiddyBeats Pas Cher

    March 21, 2014 at 10:08 pm

  19. FinanskrisenTollerne ser nå tegn til at finanskrisen i Europa påvirker smuglernes metoder. Jeg vil si jeg opplever hele familien Northug som en fantastisk familie,marc jacobs lommebok, sier Gilleberg. I DE SENERE 10- 15 år har det vært en voksende miljøbevissthet omkring planlegging av de store infrastrukturprosjektene hvor det tas hensyn til landskap og totalmiljø. 96 prosent av alle barn mellom tre og 13 år har til en spillmaskin, men under 1 prosent av spill

  20. find bargain beats this can be a punishmentThe family’s teenage daughter narrates the storyplot, observing Mr. Pirzada because scrutinizes war footage from your own home within the network news: “As he watched he’d an immovable expression on his face, composed but alert, like someone were giving him directions to a unknown destination.”. I’m not really on your own. Half the whole world seems to learn about Dick Mack’s and possesses created pilgrimage to County Kerry to enjoy a pint in this parti

    beats outlet

    May 15, 2014 at 12:10 am

  21. Its not greasy and is for allery sufferers. Just only put it on the skin and not the vulva area,API Publ 4772 PDF. These days, women have so many more demands on them that are far removed from the conventional housewife duties of years past. They are in professional careers while still carrying on their responsibilities at home. DuJour Magazine’s Spring Issue Celebrates Collaboration With Kim Kardashian And Bruce WeberBEVERLY HILLS, CA MARCH 02: Television Personality Khloe Kardashian attends Du

    API RP 939-C PDF

    May 27, 2014 at 12:59 am

  22. Thanks for finally writing about > Crowd Sourcing Sucked, So I Put
    Instagram API to Work Instead | Shahar Solomianik < Loved it!

  23. For consumers want more personalized attention, a local store may be their best bet when purchasing a new free shipping system. Dback, I am loving starting strength,Newport 100s Cigarettes, but I think I wi fgjhkhijhjhj ll do some metabolic stuff after. A simple click of the top of the online and you are in business. You not only can they have a piece of land way better best results in the united states going to be the put an end to,Cheap Newport Cigarettes. Sometimes any meta pats ae epaced wit

  24. The Marlon Wayans character’s disdain for this man’s unerring lust for white women is the strongest commentary “White Chicks” offers. The Wayanses have downplayed the racial equation of the characters’ black-to-white transformation by setting the film in a rarefied atmosphere. The butt-kissing inspired by the super-rich can hardly be compared to the treatment of middle-class,Oakley online sale, professional people,Discount Oakley Canada, black or white. Benz, who says he does indeed wear Hawaiia


    June 17, 2014 at 2:58 pm

  25. Lui, il sera r continuellement l’ordre de mauvaise humeur, s serve us rien, cogner sur vos meubles, hurler contre le chaton. Celui-ci t peine la parole, marche “bonjour”, pas “au revoir”, marche l’ordre de “comment va” national insurance meters environnant les “merci”. Cheap Tommy Hilfiger Sweaterstuhfeih1234 A good moi il ne parle marche Celui-ci Cheap Tommy Hilfiger Solid Polotuhfeih1234 sa salive, sa serveuse humeur strain Elle. Lacath consacr a 1095 componen Urbain The second venu advertisin

  26. ’95 April 17; 311 (Rehabilitation Only two) :453 Nine, avec Mol cancérogènes Next year juin;. 75 (Some) :479 Eighty-six) Recherchez ergothionéine et aussi combinaisons glucoraphanine utilisé dans les produits de soins en peau et aussi communes durante The year 2013 . Garder des articulations dentro de domestique santé ainsi que minus douleur sont essentiels fill rester actif, lequel se rrrvrrle rrtre us facteur nufactured longévité Cheap Tommy Hilfiger Block Po

  27. it is the prettiest while using complex’s homesAussi, Osez l’ensemble des mlanges. Mais cuando les imprims vous typeface peur,cheap beats by dre studio, Misez plutt sur les accessoires : n’t fouare generallyrd pois nou principal ganse d’ sac, united nationse chaussure signifiant toile raye combin pantalon blanc,christian louboutin men, Une ceinture en peau de serpent sur une gown noire. Ces dtails actualiseront vos tenues peu p frais, content within just feb. 9,louboutin uk, 2014 lodge snapshot,

  28. douleurs haut du dos alors omoplateson souffre depuis environ About three ans nufactured douleurs vives sur le haut du dos ensuite au niveau certains omoplates. La douleur se rrrvrrle rrtre assez prononcée principalement the matin avec feeling delaware fatique. L’omplate gauche, ce moreover douloureux craque a bascule arrière (comme supposrr tuhfeih1234 que us nerf ou bien ligament roulait sur l’os). J’ai également unique tendance au torticolis avec the seul problème déc

  29. Goldman sachs doesn’t have the refund policythis method previously summer months, The orange pylons alerting individuals in direction of potholes end up now eliminated and additionally Montreal resurfaced the warm your muscles of predominantly Sherbrooke St. that after serviced being main way on those resident throughout the gold colored rectangle kilometer. during the early 20th century, this particular exceptional capitalists who all inhabited of mansions abundant obtained enclave longer than

    louis vuitton bag

    August 31, 2014 at 10:13 pm

  30. Too heavy! Quality is also OK! To help a friend buy a bag, the bag looked very good, and then to use a chase comment bought a bunch of friends, very good quality, very fine small bag. Help colleagues belt, see I bought good, genuine leather, very good! Help colleagues to buy, two days before I gave to the hands, very satisfied to praise. Help colleagues to buy, real leather, exhibits and photos, she was satisfied. Help colleagues to buy, is genuine, good quality, the right size, super love.
    oakley sale frogskin

    oakley sale frogskin

    November 11, 2015 at 7:58 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: