Shahar Solomianik

Since Twitter allows only 140 characters…

The Future of In-Text Advertising

with 28 comments

In-text advertising is a controversial niche advertising market that on one hand has huge reach and on the other hand has absence of big players. It was a virtual paradise for in-text players during the last several flourishing years, but how will this niche market survive the downturn?

What is In-Text Advertising?

In-text advertising according to wikipedia is:

A form of contextual advertising where specific words within the text of a webpage are associated with advertising content.

In-text advertising is not a new type of online advertising. In its primitive form, it dates back to the early 2000’s when a company named eZula distributed an adware client that turned words into links while surfing. Later on, VibrantMedia launched intelliTXT, probably the first ever online in-text advertising product. When eZula morphed into Kontera,  they joined VibrantMedia as a leader the in-text advertising market.

The basic idea behind in-text was to bridge the traditional separation between content and ad space derived from the newspaper advertising industry. Advertising was merged into the content itself. Kontera explains this nicely in their website:

In 1982, to increase the sagging sales for Reese’s Pieces, Hershey’s accepted a product placement deal in Steven Spielberg’s “E.T.”. After Elliot used Reese’s Pieces to lure E.T. from his hiding place, Reese’s Pieces experienced a 65% increase in sales and succeeded in reinvigorating the brand. Though this wasn’t the first case of product placement, it is one of the best examples of increasing sales and supporting brand marketing objectives through contextually relevant product placement.

Low click-through rates on graphical banner ads, in contrast to the relatively high rates and conversions of CPA ads embedded as text links, gave an additional push to in-text innovation during the early days. In-text innovators tried to implement an online advertising service that could take advantage of those high click-through rates from textual links.

The Controversy

In-text advertising was, and still is, somewhat controversial. For the content consumer, it may not be so obvious that a hyper link is a sponsored ad. Some publishers and critics claim that these links are deceiving in nature, and users’ reactions are mixed. I believe this is the reason that in-text advertising is not embraced publicly. Market leaders are also aware of this.

Yet this controversy served another purpose. It appears to have prevented the big players from joining the market. The absence of Google, Yahoo, Microsoft and AOL allowed VibrantMedia and Kontera to increase their distribution and control over this niche-market. In fact, VibrantMedia and Kontera have become so dominant that regardless of their niche, they are both considered to be among the top advertising networks today. With impressive numbers such as 42% US reach for VibrantMedia and 34% US reach for Kontera, they have proven that publishers do end up implementing in-text advertising, regardless of how controversial it may be.

Today

When the online advertising industry started to flourish we saw many other networks launching their in-text services. These networks were all trying to get in on one of the only niches from which the big players were absent. Exponential’s EchoTopic, AdBrite’s Inline Ads, Clicksor and others are examples of these smaller networks.

None of these companies threatened VibrantMedia and Kontera. But on the other hand, none of them relied solely on in-text.

The lack of real competition from the big guys had its drawbacks. It didn’t drive VibrantMedia and Kontera to increase their efficiency. One of the strangest things to me is that neither company introduced a self-service interface for advertisers. Both still rely on their sales force and target only large advertisers. Moreover, they seem to prefer sharing their CPC revenue with other providers over getting higher rates themselves. Kontera is known to link its ads to Yahoo CPC ads:

The company also has access to thousands of advertisers through a partnership with Yahoo.

We can assume VibrantMedia does the same.

The Downturn

Now with this economic downturn upon us, the in-text advertising market is fragile. Because it is a controversial niche market, it may be one of the first cut from an advertiser’s budget. Moreover, as their partners begin to focus on their core business rather then nurture their in-text partnerships, VibrantMedia and Kontera will realize that relying on deals with other networks may have been a major error. Perhaps they should have developed direct relationships with advertisers as well.

In a separate issue, both VibrantMedia and Kontera rely heavily on VC funding which may also fall short in the near future.

Launching a self-service option for advertisers could help, but it may be too late. Advertisers traction is hard to gain in this environment.

The apparent solution for both companies is acquisition. Yes – their valuation may not be as high as it was last year, and yes – maybe they will not be hurt so badly from the downturn. But after all, they are VC funded start-ups looking for an exit and this downturn could be precisely what they need – a special opportunity for them to be acquired by a big player, despite the in-text controversy.

Acquisitions?

Lately, Google has demonstrated an increasing willingness to experiment with innovative, questionable and controversial advertising products. Just a few days after launching expandable ads, they also announced behavioral targeting. They are becoming more aggressive in penetrating advertising in new ways. This is understandable since Google started laying off employees and shutting projects down, proving it is not immune to the downturn. Don’t be surprised if Google enters the in-text market as well.

The question is, will Google acquire an existing player? Or will they develop their own product?

Google has shown that it acquires companies either for their distribution (YouTube, FeedBurner) or for their technology (Urchin). The bad news for VibrantMedia and Kontera is that Google neither their technology nor their distribution.

While in-text technology is not a known Google product, it may have already been developed. Even if it wasn’t, it’s not difficult for them to do. I don’t believe that Google will aquire VibrantMedia and Kontera for the amount they would like to see, especially when the technologies are so similar and could be implemented much better by Google themselves.

As for distribution, Google’s publishers network is much bigger than both VibrantMedia’s and Kontera’s. This certainly does not justify an acquisition.

So Google won’t be acquiring any of them. Who will, then?

Maybe another network will see value in their technology or distribution. Lately, Yahoo is a mystery, which leaves us with Microsoft – a great candidate for the first buyer in this market. They have the cash, they wish to expand their ad network reach, and they may be interested in in-text advertising. And, they already are working with Kontera in some capacity, which could be a catalyst for acquisition.

The Future of In-Text Advertising

If Microsoft ends up acquiring Kontera, another player (AOL? IAC?) will follow and acquire VibrantMedia. In this case, Google won’t sit on the sidelines; they will launch their own in-text advertising solution for sure. By the time we’re out of this downturn, all major players will run in-text advertising, thus legitimizing it for the future.

So all in all, if these predictions play out, the downturn will serve in-text advertising well. It won’t be lead anymore by relatively anonymous companies, and it may loose some of its charm, but it will become a legitimate way of advertising and will gain public acceptance.

And what if my predictions are wrong? Can the in-text market survive? What do you think?

Written by Shahar Solomianik

March 16th, 2009 at 9:10 am

28 Responses to 'The Future of In-Text Advertising'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'The Future of In-Text Advertising'.

  1. Fantastic Web site! I wanted to ask if I might be able to quote a portion of your site and use a couple of items for a school assignment. Please email me whether that would be fine. Thanks

  2. Nice information, many thanks to the author. It is incomprehensible to me, but in general, the usefulness and significance is overwhelming. Thanks again and good luck!

    ugg

    21 Aug 10 at 4:37 am

  3. ”’ I am really thankful to this topic because it really gives great information ;.~

    Doyle Kerchner

    29 Jan 11 at 11:39 pm

  4. I’m new to your blog and i really appreciate the nice posts and great layout.:.”`-

  5. big thanks great post

    ephesus tours

    6 Apr 11 at 8:12 pm

  6. I’ve bookmarked your weblog due to the fact I actually like it.

    Lucio Chevis

    14 Jul 11 at 4:43 am

  7. I came across this info earlier today while at the office. Very informative. Sent the website link to myself and will probably bookmark it once I get home.

    Leslie Graeser

    1 Aug 11 at 1:33 pm

  8. My wife and i have been quite excited when Louis could complete his basic research out of the ideas he obtained from your own web site. It’s not at all simplistic to simply continually be handing out tips and tricks which other folks may have been trying to sell. We already know we need the blog owner to thank for this. Those illustrations you’ve made, the straightforward web site navigation, the relationships you will make it easier to instill – it’s many astounding, and it’s really aiding our son in addition to our family know that this issue is brilliant, and that is really vital. Many thanks for the whole lot!

    Ebay Wholesale

    4 Sep 11 at 12:05 pm

  9. Hi there, I read your blog regularly. Your writing style
    is awesome, keep it up!

    Dirk

    15 Oct 12 at 7:47 am

  10. Worn first by Pierce Brosnan in Goldeneye in 1995
    (Omega Seamaster 2541:80). One of the most important things to consider is the buyer
    of the watches. Internet has revolutionized everything including the shopping experience.

    Roseann

    5 Dec 12 at 8:25 pm

  11. Hello I am so excited I found your webpage, I really
    found you by mistake, while I was looking on Bing for something else, Nonetheless I am here
    now and would just like to say kudos for a remarkable post and a all round interesting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have
    time to go through it all at the moment but I have saved it and also added your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a
    lot more, Please do keep up the superb jo.

  12. [...] is extremely comfy moderate Kvetchsyou begin the process of quite a lot through upper Korea in case you get rid of primarily 1 case of the power glass w affliction proclaimed on sunday when i first were awake to excited pet bed frames when ever gary [...]

  13. But, to be in love and bonding in every era is the same.
    United Nations (2001); Global impact: corporate leadership in the Online trading.
    With these home theater basics, you can start watching movies in theater
    style right from your couch. Just imagine how challenging it
    would be for Dev Anand to act and look like two different persons with same
    face and same costume. Attarintiki – Daaredhi tickets
    online After Pollachi schedule the shooting of the film is done
    in a huge house set erected in Ramoji Film City by art director
    Ravinder which costed around 3 crore for the producer.

  14. With that said, this is my pick for the number one movie of 2012:
    . The story revolve round incidents happened in real life before independence and is one of the most
    controversial film of the time. It has recently introduced Zune, an i – Pod competitor.
    As for the second problem, well, there is no way out.
    For example, the Los Angeles International Short Film Festival attracts nearly 15,000
    people every year.

    wheretoseek.com

    18 Sep 13 at 9:45 pm

  15. Great post. I will be facing some of these issues
    as well..

    Feel free to surf to my web-site … juicing benefits (scholarpeople.org)

    scholarpeople.org

    18 Oct 13 at 4:53 pm

  16. [wiki submission software function of GSA serp works well }|
    wiki submitter by GSA search Engine Ranker |
    Wiki Posting Poster of GSA Search Engine ranker |
    Wiki Posting function of GSA is effective |
    Effective Wiki function of GSA search engine ranker |
    Wiki Posting is effective and productive with GSA |
    GSA Wiki Posting function is effective and Worthy |
    Wiki Posting function is able to create thousand of backlink|
    New GSA Wiki Function has proven effective |
    Wiki Backlinks Creation is easy with GSA Search Engine Ranker
    GSA search engine ranker Works as well as Wiki poster software |
    GSA wiki function works well and is Able to Create Wiki Backlinks |
    Backlinks creation is easy with Wiki posting function by GSA SERP |
    Backlinks Generation is easy with Wiki Posting Function by GSA search engine Ranker |

  17. primerica employment benefits…

    The Future of In-Text Advertising | Shahar Solomianik…

  18. Opting to be taught how to play guitar for free online has
    never been easier. Playing guitar does not have anything to do with learnning guitar techniques and how well you are playing is not it at all.
    To help your improvising training your ear to pick up notes is very important
    to learn guitar tune it is usually best if you can listen to that tune
    as well as its quality.

    Feel free to visit my web site – Nikken

    Nikken

    10 Dec 13 at 4:28 am

  19. Fantastic works of art! That’s the style of facts which might be supposed to be contributed around the web. Disgrace on the search engines for no longer setting this particular offered larger! Seriously above as well as talk to this site. Many thanks Equals)

    seo software

    25 Dec 13 at 2:43 pm

  20. Stunning quest there. What occurred after? Take care!

  21. Ah seduction, that noble art. Its roots can be found in the most ancient myths; the alleged nobility is more recent, perhaps originating from mediaeval courtly love, when the beguiling of an innocent virgin (or, if you were really good, a rival’s wife) could be accomplished with flattery, favours and a joust or two. But baser motives have never been far below the surface, and, ultimately, the methods that work are the basic ones: get them to notice you in the crowd, make them feel special, win t

  22. Magnificent goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous to and you are just too great. I really like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you’re saying and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still take care of to keep it smart. I can not wait to read much more from you. This is really a tremendous web site.
    Beauty Forever The Killin It Beanies snapback hats wholesale http://www.occdocnj.com/fckeditor/hats.cfm?p=Beauty-Forever-The-Killin-It-Beanies-snapback-hats-wholesale.html

  23. Hmm is anyone else having problems with the images
    on this blog loading? I’m trying to find out
    if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog. Any feed-back would be greatly appreciated.

    Janessa

    27 Feb 14 at 11:16 am

  24. Do you know your Billiga Parajumpers policies and procedures inside and out? Also, the concept art suggests a bronze rather than blue cast. And one last thought from Roll ghggfdgsdg ey, who said that he was wary of single-name credit default swaps because managing the counterparty risk was so onerous. A parajumpers outerwear made of neurons taken from leeches has been created by US scientists. It’s complemented by ultra-fast Wireless-N Wi-Fi networking (802. If a power chord shape has it’s root

  25. I have read so many content on the topic of the blogger lovers except this article is really a
    good paragraph, keep it up.

    gem hack cheat

    8 Mar 14 at 4:14 pm

  26. We aare a group off volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community.

    Yoour website offered us with valuable information to work on.
    You have done a formidable job and our entire community will be thankful to
    you.

  27. Hi there would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re using?

    I’m going to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a
    tough time deciding between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution
    and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design seems different then most blogs and
    I’m looking for something completely unique. P.S Sorry for getting off-topic but I had
    to ask!

    Review my homepage … Dental Filling Cost

  28. Thank you, I have just been looking for information approximately this subject for a while and yours
    is the best I have discovered till now. But, what about the conclusion?
    Are you positive about the source?

Leave a Reply